
Mastering Milk Paint Finishes on Flat Surfaces
, by Ryan Casuga, 5 min reading time
, by Ryan Casuga, 5 min reading time
Have you ever spotted a gorgeous aged piece of furniture and thought, "I could never recreate that finish"? Think again! With the right techniques and a little patience, you can achieve that same beautifully cracked, vintage look using milk paint—even on flat surfaces!
In this blog post, we’ll walk you through how to create an authentic, timeworn finish on furniture, using layers of crack gesso, milk paint, wax, and antiquing glaze.
Let’s dive in!
Milk paint is one of the most versatile and natural ways to create an authentic aged look. Unlike traditional paints, milk paint reacts uniquely with different surfaces, creating natural cracking, chipping, and layering for a truly historic effect.
If you’ve struggled to get milk paint to work on smooth, flat surfaces, this guide will take the mystery out of it!
Start with a clean, dry surface. If your piece is raw wood, you’re in luck! If it’s previously finished, clean it thoroughly with Clean Slate and scuff it lightly with sandpaper for better adhesion.
If you want a rich, natural wood tone to peek through your finish, apply Gel Stain in English Walnut. Brush it on, working the stain into the wood grain, then wipe off the excess with a rag. Let it dry.
Mix Crack Gesso with equal parts water and stir well. Apply a full coat over your stained surface. This layer creates the necessary "tooth" to help the milk paint adhere and crack naturally.
Use a candle or Light Wax to rub along areas where natural wear would occur—edges, handles, and high-touch areas. This will make the top layers of paint naturally flake away later.
For this finish, we created a custom taupey-brown by mixing Sunday Supper milk paint with Praying Wife.
The key to achieving a true black is slacking the Nor Pigment separately in water before mixing it into the Nor Milk Paint.
Once your paint is mixed:
Don’t worry—this will all come together in the next step!
Now comes the fun part! Use a sea sponge to apply Antiquing Glaze. This step reactivates the milk paint, allowing you to distress and reveal the underlying layers.
Use a gentle "hit and drag" motion to lift some of the black and expose the brown underneath. Focus on areas that would naturally wear over time, like drawer handles, edges, and corners.
Once your paint is fully dry:
This adds an authentic, aged patina that makes your piece look like it came straight from an antique shop!
Using this technique, we transformed a plain, flat wooden surface into something that looks like it’s been aged for centuries.
✔ Furniture like dressers, cabinets, and secretaries.
✔ Flat panel doors and drawers.
✔ Decorative wooden boxes or frames.
✨ Happy painting! ✨